The recent news concerning Microsoft Copilot+, the new AI-powered platform developed jointly by Microsoft and its OEM partners, reveals a complex landscape with promising innovations paired with notable limitations and challenges across various aspects.
Battery Life receives positive attention due to the integration of specialized Neural Processing Units (NPUs) in Copilot+ devices, which Microsoft and industry analysts highlight as significantly more power-efficient than traditional GPUs for AI tasks. This efficiency is particularly advantageous for laptops and portable PCs, as it prolongs battery runtime when running AI features locally. However, there is no explicit detailed battery benchmarking available in the news, so the extent of improvement remains partially anecdotal.
System Performance is enhanced through dedicated AI hardware accelerators (NPUs) enabling real-time AI-driven features such as intelligent text actions, voice control in settings, and localized small language models (e.g., Phi Silica). These features bring a seamless and responsive user experience on supported Copilot+ devices. Yet, the performance gains hinge on the presence of requisite NPUs, which are only available on specific laptop and mobile CPU configurations, limiting desktop performance benefits currently.
Hardware compatibility emerges as a key dividing line in the current Copilot+ ecosystem. The platform mandates qualified NPUs for AI functionalities, excluding many traditional desktops—even premium gaming PCs powered by AMD or Intel—because their CPUs lack sufficient or any NPU support. While some lightweight PCs with mobile processors qualify, the lack of desktop-class NPU solutions and the absence of GPU fallback support restrict the reach of Copilot+ features. This means a substantial segment of existing PCs is unable to leverage the platform’s AI enhancements, causing confusion and dissatisfaction among users expecting broader hardware support.
On the Software front, Copilot+ introduces intelligent features like AI agents integrated directly into Windows 11’s Settings app, and "Click to Do" smart text actions such as summarization and tone-adaptive rewriting. These leverage on-device AI models to improve usability and productivity without continuous cloud reliance. However, features are currently limited in language support (primarily English), are in early preview or Insider builds, and involve mandatory Microsoft account sign-in for full functionality. The staged rollout and experimental status suggest software maturity and feature completeness are still evolving.
Security and Privacy concerns arise from the requirement that users sign in with Microsoft or Microsoft Entra accounts to access AI features. While on-device processing reduces cloud data transfer risk, the account linkage and telemetry inherent in cloud-adjacent Microsoft ecosystems might raise privacy questions among users wary of extensive data collection. Additionally, some users’ resistance to AI-enabled defaults and concerns related to disabling AI features entirely point to an ongoing trust and transparency challenge.
When it comes to Compatibility, aside from the strict hardware NPU demands excluding many desktops and older devices, the current software features exhibit partial multilingual support and selective availability depending on CPU architecture and Windows Insider status. This fragmented compatibility indicates Microsoft is still in the early phases of broadening Copilot+ accessibility, and users of older PCs or those unwilling/unable to enroll in Insider programs might be left out for the foreseeable future.
Reliability of Copilot+ features currently shows mixed impressions. Early adopters have reported occasional delays or long wait times on initial feature use post-updates, while AI recommendations in system settings may sometimes be inaccurate, thus requiring user vigilance. The platform's rollout of experimental features with ongoing feedback cycles implies that stability and polish will improve with time but are not guaranteed at this stage.
In summary, the Microsoft Copilot+ platform embodies a forward-looking integration of AI into the PC experience with clear benefits in power efficiency and novel intelligent features. However, its strict reliance on specialized hardware NPUs restricts adoption primarily to newer mobile-device classes, leaving many desktops and powerful PCs unable to participate currently. The software innovations offer promising productivity and accessibility tools but introduce privacy considerations and require users to adapt to ongoing feature evolution. As Microsoft continues expanding hardware support and refining software capabilities, Copilot+ could significantly alter user interactions with Windows PCs, though today's landscape requires informed consideration of device compatibility, privacy, and readiness to engage with cutting-edge but still maturing technology.
AI REQUEST ERROR: empty prompt value for Microsoft Copilot+, which is a new computer hardware platform developed by Microsoft and its OEMs (...
| Key positive aspects of Copilot+ | Key concerns related to Copilot+ |
|---|---|
| Copilot+ AI features require a qualified NPU, providing optimized AI processing on supported devices. | No desktop PCs currently meet the hardware requirements (qualified NPU) for Copilot+ AI features, excluding even high-end gaming PCs. |
| NPUs offer a balance of performance and power efficiency for AI tasks, especially beneficial for laptops. | Intel’s desktop NPUs are not fast enough, and AMD desktop CPUs lack NPUs, limiting desktop AI capability. |
| Copilot+ encourages third-party developers to integrate the “Copilot Runtime” to utilize NPU acceleration in their apps (e.g., DaVinci Resolve). | Restricting Copilot Runtime usage only to NPUs prevents the use of GPUs or CPUs, limiting flexibility and wider adoption. |
| Copilot+ features continue to expand with new functionalities announced by Microsoft, indicating ongoing commitment. | Lack of support for running AI features on GPUs means many existing AI-capable PCs cannot use Copilot+ features. |
| Some lightweight mini PCs with mobile CPUs are supported, expanding the range of compatible hardware beyond traditional laptops. | The requirement for NPUs excludes many current AI laptops and all desktops, causing confusion over what constitutes an “AI PC.” |
| Copilot+ NPUs are more power efficient than GPUs, improving battery life for AI processing on portable devices. | This limitation forces consumers to choose between waiting for future desktop NPUs or foregoing Copilot+ features altogether. |
AI REQUEST ERROR: empty prompt value for Microsoft Copilot+, which is a new computer hardware platform developed by Microsoft and its OEMs (...
| Key positive aspects of Copilot+ | Key concerns related to Copilot+ |
|---|---|
| AI-focused hardware integration enabling new generation Windows experiences including AI agents in Settings app on Snapdragon Copilot+ PCs. | AI features may cause controversy with some users preferring no AI on their PCs. |
| Intelligent text actions like Summarize, Create a bulleted list, and text rewriting (casual, formal, polished) for AMD and Intel-powered Copilot+ PCs. | AI-driven features require users to be signed in with Microsoft or Microsoft Entra accounts, raising privacy or account concerns. |
| Click to Do feature uses the on-device Small Language Model (Phi Silica) for local AI processing without cloud dependency. | Current AI features primarily support English language and may limit accessibility for non-English speakers. |
| Settings app AI agent can understand user intent and automate tasks like controlling PC by voice or changing settings. | Some users may be concerned about the default enablement or difficulty fully disabling AI features on Windows 11 PCs. |
| Dedicated FAQ section in Settings for easier system configuration, performance, and compatibility information on Copilot+ PCs. | AI features rollout might be initially limited to specific hardware platforms like Snapdragon-powered devices before wider availability. |
| Key positive aspects of Copilot+ | Key concerns related to Copilot+ |
|---|---|
| Introduction of an AI agent in the Settings app to help Copilot+ PC owners find and select settings easily using conversational language. | AI recommendations for settings may sometimes be incorrect, requiring user caution. |
| Leverages the NPU (Neural Processing Unit) on Copilot+ devices for enhanced AI capabilities. | Currently only supports English language for the AI agent. |
| AI can recommend specific setting choices and simplify customization or troubleshooting. | Initial testing is limited to Copilot+ devices with Snapdragon processors; AMD and Intel support is forthcoming. |
| New hardware-related FAQ in the Settings app provides detailed explanations of PC specs and expected performance impacts. | The hardware FAQ feature is new and not yet integrated with existing PC spec info cards, which may reduce usability. |
| Aims to help less experienced users understand hardware capabilities and settings more intuitively. | AI's accuracy and effectiveness remain to be seen based on user feedback during this early testing phase. |
| Key positive aspects of Copilot+ | Key concerns related to Copilot+ |
|---|---|
| Introduction of intelligent text actions in the Click to Do feature for AMD and Intel-powered Copilot+ PCs. | Intelligent text actions in Click to Do may experience long wait times on first use after a build or model update. |
| Users can select text and perform actions like summarizing, creating bulleted lists, or rewriting in various tones. | Spanish and French support for Click to Do is currently limited, with full rewrite options pending future updates. |
| Intelligent text actions are powered by Phi Silica, an on-device Small Language Model (SLM) built into Windows. | Narrator’s richer image descriptions and Voice Access’s flexible language support on Copilot+ PCs are under investigation for issues. |
| Features are available for users signed in with a Microsoft or Microsoft Entra account and meet language/word criteria. | |
| Supports enterprise users via Entra ID integration in tools like Paint and Notepad with features like Cocreator and Generative Fill. | |
| Gradual rollout of features with faster access for users enabling the update toggle in Windows Update. | |
| Accessibility features like Recall and Click to Do being introduced (though may not fully function in preview). |
Source: https://cybersecuritynews.com/microsoft-windows-11-insider-preview-build-26200-5600-released/
| Key positive aspects of Copilot+ | Key concerns related to Copilot+ |
|---|---|
| Smart text actions in Click to Do feature allow quick summarizing, bullet points, or rewriting of selected text using built-in shortcuts. | Feature currently available only in Windows 11 Insider Program, indicating limited early access. |
| Users can change the tone of the rewritten text from casual to polished or formal on the go, enhancing communication flexibility. | Being an experimental feature, it may have bugs or incomplete functionalities. |
| Powered by Microsoft’s local small language model Phi Silica, which processes text directly on-device without requiring online connectivity. | Users must have specific builds and verify system information to use the feature properly. |
| The feature integrates seamlessly across apps, making quick edits easier without needing a full editor. | No specific mention of compatibility beyond AMD and Intel Copilot+ PCs; potential hardware limitations. |
| Immediate output with ability to copy results directly to clipboard improves workflow efficiency. | Feedback mechanism implies ongoing development and possible instability. |
Source: https://mspoweruser.com/microsoft-smart-text-actions-on-copilot-pcs/